Discussion: GAiIT Level 5
Promoting Discussion
One of these two entries was generated by ChatGPT 4o using the following prompt:
Imagine you are a student at a university in a teacher credentialing program. Read the prompt and then answer the question.
Prompt: The critic cites the notion that Maslow’s research into the Blackfoot Indian Tribe revealed that his notion of self-actualization was in fact upside down. The Blackfoot saw self-actualization as inherent and at the base of the pyramid rather than at the top. The tribe leaders noted that actualization was the act of believing one’s ability to constantly strive begins at birth and it’s the community that nourishes this idea.
Answer this: create personalized response based on their own experiences both as a student and thinking as a teacher to the following question: “Is Maslow’s Hierarchy inherent to the human experience or is it a learned construct created by our community culture?”
Additional questions for further discussion:
- Which one of the two entries was generated by the prompt listed previously?
- What criteria did you use to determine the Ai generated response? Discuss all that apply here.
- What do you feel was the instructional goal of the assignment?
- This assignment was classified as a GAiIT Level 5 by the instructor. Why did the instructor insist on the use of this level?
- What course of action should the instructor take when addressing the student’s disregard for the G5 designation?
Next: Evidence of generative Ai use at GAiIT Level 5